Choosing a home warranty company can feel overwhelming. With so many providers promising great service and coverage, how do you know which one to trust? Here’s a review and comparison of the top 5 home warranty companies to help you decide.

1. American Home Shield (AHS)
Pros:

Covers a wide range of systems and appliances

Customizable plans

No home inspection required

Cons:

Higher-than-average monthly premiums

Mixed customer service reviews

Best For: Homeowners seeking flexibility in coverage.

2. Choice Home Warranty
Pros:

Affordable pricing

24/7 claims support

Standard plans cover most essential appliances

Cons:

Less customizable

Limited contractor network in some areas

Best For: First-time buyers and budget-conscious homeowners.

3. Select Home Warranty
Pros:

Competitive pricing

Frequent promotional offers

Covers roof leaks in basic plan

Cons:

Limited coverage caps

May take time to dispatch technicians

Best For: Homeowners looking for roof coverage.

4. Liberty Home Guard
Pros:

A+ BBB rating

Optional add-ons for luxury appliances and electronics

Fast claims processing

Cons:

Slightly more expensive

Requires pre-approval for some repairs

Best For: Tech-savvy homeowners with modern systems.

5. First American Home Warranty
Pros:

Great for older homes

Generous appliance replacement terms

Straightforward contracts

Cons:

No coverage for roof or HVAC add-ons

Higher service fees

Best For: Owners of older properties with aging appliances.

Conclusion
Each company has strengths and weaknesses. If flexibility is key, go with AHS. For affordability, Choice or Select are solid picks. Tech-forward homeowners may prefer Liberty, while First American is ideal for older homes.